Forgotten Americans
Abstract:
Imagine a place where bathing is a process that includes going outside a trailer and filling up a bucket of water, coming inside and boiling it and repeating these steps several times so there is an adequate amount of water to actually bathe in....
- Displaying 1 - 11 of 11
bordergirl
posted 3/07/08 @ 10:45 AM CST
Originally posted byMatt
I have one question for the author of this sad story--How many of these residents of the colonias are US citizens and how many are illegal aliens?
I suspect that the majority of the residents are illegals--and you think teaching them how to grab onto the American welfare system is something we should be proud of as Aggies? Why not just deport them back to where they came from?
This response is typical of a well-fed American who has never been to the border to see how other people live. Not everyone in the world can afford the shopping habit of comfortably ignorant Americans.
Most colonias residents are American, not illegal. These are not hide out locations. These are small neighborhoods of little houses, where the neighbors know each other, and multiple generation families live cramped spaces. Some homes have running water, some might have electricity, all are families trying to make it on very limited income.
Its not a racial/immigration issue. Its one of economics.
Those who are privileged with wealth are quick to judge those who do not share the same circumstances. Visit a colonia neighborhood before you publish hateful comments.
Amy (Class of 89)
posted 2/26/08 @ 8:56 AM CST
We are proud to be Aggies because of the longstanding tradition that we continue to uphold--helping others. Aggies don't base their generosity on citizenship.
Anonymous
posted 2/26/08 @ 11:47 AM CST
No one has a responsbility to help them, particularly not the state. They weren't forced to live there, instead they chose to live there without government approval. They're shanty towns set up by illegals. If there's any citizens there, I'd bet that most of them are the offspring of the illegals that were lucky enough to arrive in the US before they gave birth (Thanks alot 14th ammendment). The solution is to bulldoze the freakin places to the ground before the disease and filth spreads to cities.
Rex
posted 2/26/08 @ 2:34 PM CST
I thought this sort of living condition was reserved for Africa or Asia. I'm surprised to know we have so many people living in the colonias. Thanks for an informative and eye-opening piece. Stories like this do bring out the prejudicially disadvantaged. Its hard for the bigoted to sit back and let pass an opportunity to express their animosity for our neighbors from the South.
duncan
posted 2/26/08 @ 5:38 PM CST
what some people fail to understand is that the conditions that these colonias are in have very little to no difference than the conditions where the inhabitants have come from. if the inhabitants found it intolerable, they would not live there. does anyone else see the irony of this sentence? "The vast majority of colonia residents are citizens of the United States." if a father and mother from mexico come across the border and have 4 kids, the vast majority of that population is now a u.s. citizen. these people do need help and we should help them but first we need to build a very effective fence along our borders otherwise we will end up helping all of mexico's poor-and that's mexicos job, not ours.
bordergirl
posted 3/07/08 @ 10:55 AM CST
RACISM = racial prejudice + power
If we hate Mexico so much, why don't we stop importing/exporting goods from them? Why don't we pass a law preventing Americans from buying Mexican land/property and businesses? Why don't we pass laws preventing American companies from owning factories in Mexico, factories that don't have to follow the environmental laws on either side of the border?
Our economy would collapse. Then we'd have to admit that Mexicans are just like us, humans.
If we hate Mexico so much, why don't we stop importing/exporting goods from them? Why don't we pass a law preventing Americans from buying Mexican land/property and businesses? Why don't we pass laws preventing American companies from owning factories in Mexico, factories that don't have to follow the environmental laws on either side of the border?
Our economy would collapse. Then we'd have to admit that Mexicans are just like us, humans.
Jeremy'05
posted 3/07/08 @ 2:34 PM CST
Originally posted bybordergirl
RACISM = racial prejudice + power
If we hate Mexico so much, why don't we stop importing/exporting goods from them? Why don't we pass a law preventing Americans from buying Mexican land/property and businesses? Why don't we pass laws preventing American companies from owning factories in Mexico, factories that don't have to follow the environmental laws on either side of the border?
Our economy would collapse. Then we'd have to admit that Mexicans are just like us, humans.
WRONG!!
First, why don't we patrol our southern border the same way mexico patrols it's southern border.(with loaded rifles, and shooting to kill anything in sight that is illegally entering mexico.)
Second, the last time I checked, it is not possible for an American, or any non-mexican citizen to OWN land, houses or any type of property in mexico. I believe you can own the structure on top of the dirrt, but not the dirt itself. you actually lease the dirt from the govt. As for condo's - I really don't know the specific law regarding that, but will assume that the same applies to non mexican nationals.
Third, I do agree with you on preventing American companies from taking the industrial companies out of the U.S. to find cheaper wages, the U.S. middle class is almost gone because of that, the U.S. govt should tax the hell out of those companies who do this.
We would do quite all right without mexican imports/exports.
haha -
mexican imports = drugs mexican exports = illegal criminal immigrants
Texas could pretty much supply the U.S. with many of it's agricultural and industrial goods (which could be harvested by prisoners)
Bottom line is - we don't need mexico for anything, except a cheap place to vacation.
bordergirl
posted 3/07/08 @ 10:58 AM CST
These responses are typical of well-fed Americans who have never been to the border to see how other people live. Not everyone in the world can afford the shopping habit of comfortably ignorant Americans.
Most colonias residents are American, not illegal. These are not hide out locations. These are small neighborhoods of little houses, where the neighbors know each other, and multiple generation families live cramped spaces. Some homes have running water, some might have electricity, all are families trying to make it on very limited income.
Its not a racial/immigration issue. Its one of economics.
Those who are privileged with wealth are quick to judge those who do not share the same circumstances. Visit a colonia neighborhood before you publish hateful comments.
Most colonias residents are American, not illegal. These are not hide out locations. These are small neighborhoods of little houses, where the neighbors know each other, and multiple generation families live cramped spaces. Some homes have running water, some might have electricity, all are families trying to make it on very limited income.
Its not a racial/immigration issue. Its one of economics.
Those who are privileged with wealth are quick to judge those who do not share the same circumstances. Visit a colonia neighborhood before you publish hateful comments.
Marie
posted 3/11/08 @ 8:41 PM CST
According to the Border Census Data 97% of all individuals residing in Colonias are American Citizens. Why then live in Colonias? The American Dream...own your poperty. Most individuals seeking a piece of porperty in which to build a home will consider their finances. Real estate research shows that homes and poperty outside the city limits are more affordable. Do people who are working at minimum wage jobs have less of a right to own a home? No, they simply live within their means.
Colonia residents have the same aspirations and dreams as urban residents. The difference is social economic levels not citizenship.
Colonia residents have the same aspirations and dreams as urban residents. The difference is social economic levels not citizenship.
Erwan
posted 4/01/08 @ 5:32 AM CST
This is an interesting debate,
Before I could give an answer, I have to know what is a Colonia etc etc.
Marie, where did you get those informations (97% of all individuals residing in Colonias are American Citizens), do you have pictures?
Alexis Arguello: where did you get your infomrations too?
I would like to know what is life in Colonias.
Thanks to answer.
Before I could give an answer, I have to know what is a Colonia etc etc.
Marie, where did you get those informations (97% of all individuals residing in Colonias are American Citizens), do you have pictures?
Alexis Arguello: where did you get your infomrations too?
I would like to know what is life in Colonias.
Thanks to answer.
- Displaying 1 - 11 of 11
Post Your Comment
Remembering 2:42
News
Volleyball back in win column
Sports
'Riverdance' comes to OPAS on farewell tour
Features
A sweet deal
Features
Turning up my nose up to 'taste'
Opinion
Aggies are we
Opinion
We'd like to feature some extraordinary Aggies who have their own special story to tell. Please submit your nominations to battcopy@thebatt.com
Spring Break






Matt
posted 2/26/08 @ 1:29 AM CST
I suspect that the majority of the residents are illegals--and you think teaching them how to grab onto the American welfare system is something we should be proud of as Aggies? Why not just deport them back to where they came from?