Quantcast The Battalion
College Media Network
  • ©2009 Student Media

Fuming Mad

Abstract:
On June 11, the U.S. Senate passed legislation enabling the Food and Drug Administration to impose stricter controls on the manufacturing and marketing of cigarettes.

The government has overreached its authority again by granting itself the power to alter even the taste and names of cigarettes in a noble effort to force citizens to make the right choice regarding health....

  • Displaying 1 - 4 of 4

Susan

posted 7/02/09 @ 9:29 AM CST

I'm torn on this... I'm not a smoker, but I feel that adults should be able to do whatever they please, provided it does not harm anyone else. As such, all you smokers should be able to puff away 24x7 if you want, away from non-smokers. While it would be nice if people stopped smoking for their own health, it's not the government's place to tell them that.

But... A number of health problems are linked directly to smoking. According to the National Cancer Institute, smoking can lead to cancers of the lung, trachea, bronchus, larynx, pharynx, oral cavity, nasal cavity, and esophagus. It has even been linked to cancers in the digestive system, as well as leukemia. They also believe cigarettes are responsible for 25% of dealth from house fires.

So... I'll make a deal with you. You just keep on smokin', but when you get cancer or your house burns down, don't expect any insurance money or taxpayer paid services for your self-inflicted injuries. Insurance won't pay for self-inflicted wounds, so why should it pay for self-inflicted cancer?

robert

posted 7/02/09 @ 1:57 PM CST

Enjoyed Ian's take on Government power over smoking. thanks Robert.

Edward

posted 7/04/09 @ 2:28 PM CST

This is about forcing tobacco companies to be honest about their products. Consumers can't make informed decisions about products if the companies are permitted to lie at every turn about the health effects of their products. Naming cigarettes "lites" or making claims that these particular cigarettes are less unhealthy that are provably false is unfair and ought to be illegal. Only someone who's hate for any and all government has blinded them could be against regulating the claims that purveyors of known harmful products can make.

Ol Ag

posted 7/06/09 @ 9:44 AM CST

I do not believe that the reason is because the government is trying to control everything...it's about HEALTH CARE! The cost of health care is alarmingly high. The government is in a predicament to try to come up with ways to make health care affordable to EVERY American. Who foots a majority of the bill? The tax payer. A GREAT deal of health problems can be attributed to smoking. Therefore, taxing those that contribute to the problem the most makes sense. Smokers CHOOSE to smoke and get sick and have a multitude of health problems. There are some unfortunate people out there who contract diseases that have a led a healthy life. So, why is it that they have to go bankrupt because of it? By increasing the tax, the government is trying to convince people to STOP smoking, therefore, decreasing the health problems and improving the cost of health care.
The tax is not without good reason.
  • Displaying 1 - 4 of 4

Post Your Comment

  • NOTE: Email address will not be published

Type your comment below (html not allowed)

  I understand posting spam or other comments that are unrelated to this article will cause my comment to be flagged for deletion and possibly cause my IP address to be permanently banned from this server.

Advertisement

In Today's Print

 

Just In (AP Lead Stories)

Advertisement

  • Podcasts
  • Videos